Best Seafood (city): Dobutsu

Photos by kc kratt

 

Best seafood (city)

Dobutsu

500 Seneca St., Buffalo; 322-6004 or dobutsubuffalo.com

Toutant’s chef and owner James Roberts opened his much-anticipated California-inspired seafood spot in May. Fish here is prepared carefully and simply. It’s also served a la carte, so be sure to order a few appetizers for the table. Roberts is bringing fish in fresh from the coast daily, an effort we’re grateful for, especially since it’s an unusual (and expensive) choice for Western New York restaurant operators. Cod, tuna, halibut, or salmon—you can see the quality in the seafood case located near the front door.

 

Best seafood (suburbs)

Remington Tavern and Seafood Exchange

184 Sweeney St., North Tonawanda; 362-2802 or remingtontavern.com/wordpress

If Remington’s massive raw bar stocked with fresh clams and multiple varieties of boutique oysters isn’t your thing, there are other options. Clams can be steamed or casino style, and oysters grilled or broiled Rockefeller. Friday fish fries skews from the ubiquitous cod/haddock formula for locally slanted yellow pike, which is available daily in appetizer format. Standards like farmed salmon, yellow fin tuna, shrimp, and scallops come with out-of-the-ordinary preparations.   

 

Best Poke

Fresh Catch Poke Co.

5933 Main St., Williamsville; 271-7653 or freshcatchpoke.co

Poke couldn’t have been more on trend in 2017 and with the dearth of high-quality fresh fish in WNY restaurants, the arrival of Fresh Catch was well-timed. We can’t decide what we like better, the house selections or the DIY bowls we dream up for ourselves, but the bamboo rice is downright ambrosial and we can’t say enough about the fish and toppings. Unfamiliar with poke? If you’re a sushi eater, you’ll love this place!

 

Best fish fry (city)

Joe’s Deli

Multiple locations; joesdelionline.com

Not sure we can count all the awards we’ve given Joe and the team at Joe’s Deli, or the number of times we’ve featured them in the magazine, but all those awards and mentions are well-deserved. Joe’s is just as good today as it was when it first came to town and made our sandwich dreams come true. Its fish fry is equally excellent, with scratchmade sides and a fish fry system (yes, that’s a thing) that seems unbreakable, given that the tiny Hertel location alone fields hundreds of fish fry orders on any Lenten evening. In fact, it’s so popular, Joe’s added it to the daily menu a couple years ago. Did you hear that, WNY? Now you can get your fish fry on anytime!

 

Best fish fry (northtowns)

The Audubon North

3050 Sweet Home Rd., Amherst; 691-9248 or facebook.com/TheAudubon

A well-kept secret among area residents, Audubon offers hearty renditions of Buffalo classics every day. From epic chicken fingers to beef on ’weck, from crispy wings to sauteed pierogi, Audubon is the kind of throwback bar that just doesn’t exist any more. With a traditional fish fry that hangs off the plate and sides the size of most entrees, there’s no denying this joint is a little old-school, but we’ll take that classic WNY fare and hospitality as often as we can get it.

 

Best fish fry (southtowns)

Wiechec’s lounge

174 Clinton St., Buffalo or 823-2828

Fish frys rule on Fridays at Wiechec’s, and we know, because it’s impossible to get an order of wings! The dedicated fryer insures a delicious, freshly fried fish fillet (say that ten times) every time. The golden brown fish is  balanced atop perfectly prepared fries, coleslaw, and both potato and mac salads. Easy to see why this place is always nominated for the fish fry prize. After all that, it’s probably gluttonous to suggest that you should try to leave room for a cup of clam chowder, but we’re doing it anyway. Really, we insist.

 

Best gluten-free fish fry

Kith & Kin Bake Shop & Bistro

6429 Dysinger Rd., Lockport; 471-3305 or kkbakeshop.com

This charming cafe is 100 percent gluten-free. There are paninis, sandwiches, and wraps, as well as a Friday-only fish fry. The biggest raves K&K gets are for items that normally have gluten, so you know they’re doing something right. Just note that K&K closes at 6 on weekdays and even earlier on weekends.

 

Best steak (city)

SEAR Steakhouse

200 Delaware Ave., Buffalo; 319-1090 or searbuffalo.comhttp://searbuffalo.com

Located in the Avant and co-owned by Dave Schutte (Oliver’s) with a smattering of esteemed businessmen and Buffalo Bills, it’s safe to say there’s a fair amount of steak know-how happening here. Prime beef is available in signature cuts, American kobe from Snake River Farms can be ordered in a varying level of A ratings and cuts, and farm-raised options are punctuated by the day’s Butcher’s Cut. While some folks prefer a sauce or compound butter with their favorite steak (and at SEAR those are made from scratch), we think the steak is of good enough quality and preparation that just a little salt and pepper is required. It’s also important to note that SEAR’s wide range of delicious made-from-scratch appetizers and sides are a steakhouse rarity we can’t emphasize enough.

 

Best steak (northtowns)

>>> Tie

Giancarlo’s Sicilian Steakhouse

5110 Main St., Williamsville; 650-5566 or giancarlossteakhouse.com

 

Russell’s Steaks, Chops & More

6675 Transit Rd., Williamsville; 636-4900 or salvatoresgrand.com/russells-steakhouse

Giancarlo’s is one of the few places executing an approachable fine dining experience in the Northtowns, and they’re doing it well. The place is packed most nights, and while there’s a wide array of entrees available, the steak is often recommended by regulars. The bone-in rib eye, cooked sous vide before it’s seared on a hot grill, is like meat butter. Wagyu, prime cuts, tender little petite filets—they’re all here.

You’d be hard-pressed to find the kind of old school-Buffalo hospitality Russell’s has in spades. And steaks—let’s not leave out the steaks! Pick your cut, order sides for the table and a bottle of wine, sit back, and relax! You’re at Russell Salvatore’s place!

 

Best charcuterie (city)    

Craving

1472 Hertel Ave., Buffalo; 883-1675 or cravingbuffalo.com

From bread and pasta to pickles and charcuterie, everything at Craving is not only made in-house, it’s often local, too. The house’s charcuterie program uses pork from Erba Verde Farm, and chef Adam Goetz, along with his sous, Ken Mogford, employ certain cuts to create guanciale, culatello, copa, and salumi. Once it’s ready, they cook with it—rendering all of the fat for frying, and using the end pieces for brodo—but it’s also served as a charcuterie plate, gloriously augmented with housemade pickles and mustard.

 

Best charcuterie (suburbs)

AC Meat Company

6472 Southwestern Blvd., Lake View; 980-3018 or acmeatcompany.com

Located in Lake View, a hamlet of Hamburg, AC Meat Company took the popular vote in this year’s Best Ofs, and we think it may be because of its beloved and revered Beef Bouquet! Made of house-cured jerky (bbq cajun and soy/ginger), beef sticks and pepperoni, it comes wrapped in a beer mug, ready for your favorite carnivore. If delicious handmade sausages are also your thing, AC’s got some of those, too.

 

Best charcuterie (retail)    

Battistoni Italian Specialty Meats

81 Dingens St, Buffalo; 826-2700 or battistonibrand.com

From cappicolla to chorizo, Battistoni has been an artisan-founded supplier since 1931, providing both businesses and home cooks with excellent Italian dry-cured meats. Battistoni has recently added an organic line.

 

Best food truck

Lomo Lomo

341-3299 or lomofoodtruck.com

Lomo Lomo is the truck to beat! We said the same last year, so if you didn’t listen then, now is the time. Global flavors? Check. Original creations? Check. Large portions? Check. Reliable and consistent quality? Check.

 

Best new hotspot (southtowns)

The General Riley House

644 Oakwood Ave., East Aurora; or elmstreetbakery.com

Elm Street Bakery has dominated the East Aurora food scene since its opening, but this year it one-upped itself by launching Riley House. Utilizing an adjacent historic home, the tiny but intimate private room is ideal for entertaining fewer than forty people—a rental space size that’s needed here, but really hard to find. Baby showers, birthday parties, wine dinners, graduation parties, and other small events have quickly found homes here, augmented by the baked goods and customer service ESB’s fans have come to love and expect.

 

Best brunch (city)

>>> Tie

Toutant

437 Ellicott St., Buffalo; 342-2901 or toutantbuffalo.com

The Black Sheep Restaurant & Bar

367 Connecticut St., Buffalo; 884-1100 or blacksheepbuffalo.com

It’s a tough call: a Southern brunch featuring deep-fried deliciousness and top notch customer service, or a globally inspired porkcentric breakfast feast? Whichever you may choose, the one thing the brunch offerings at Toutant and Black Sheep have in common is fantastic pastries, so bring your appetite. Whether you’re out with friends, attempting to appease a hangover, or taking mom for a bite after church, Toutant or Black Sheep have got you covered.

 

Best brunch (southtowns)

Carte Blanche

61 Buffalo St., Hamburg; 649-2101 or carteblanchehamburg.com

photo by kc kratt

 

What could be better than all of the decadence of brunch with none of the chaos? Carte Blance serves up instagrammable choices like a stuffed popover carefully overflowing with eggs and sausage, poached eggs perched just so on an English muffin or plate of hash, and an indulgent salt caramel French toast, topped with a bruleed, custard-like layer. Pitchers of brunch cocktails are available, as is high-quality French press coffee. As good as the food is, and it is good, what really sets Carte Blanche apart is its attention to details, accepting reservations and providing fast but unharried service even at peak hour, as well as a sleek environment free from jostling or drafts. If you want to brunch like a grownup and can count on your friends to make a reservation you secured in advance, Carte Blanche is your go to.

 

Best bloody mary (city)

Sophia’s restaurant

749 Military Rd., Buffalo; 447-9661 or sophiasrestaurant716.com

Sophia’s doesn’t do anything the easy way. Or in moderation. Everything at this Military Road diner is made from scratch and super-sized; its bloody mary is no exception. Sporting a veritable parade of accouterments, from slices of bacon and dilly beans to lemon wedges and jalapenos, Sophia’s serves the most Instagrammable brunch sidekick we’ve found. Cheers!

 

Best bloody mary (suburbs)

YOLO restaurant + lounge    

5841 Transit Rd., East Amherst; 688-4479 or yolobuffalony.com

Brunch acolytes, your fave meal of the week is served every day until 4 p.m. at the one and only YOLO on Transit. Obviously, mimosas and bloodies are on the menu, but here the bloody marys are, as they call them, “loaded.” Bacon, grilled shrimp, lemons, an assortment of spices, green olives, and lemon wedges mean this bloody eats like an appetizer.

 

Best coffeeshop (city)

Tipico Coffee

128 Fargo Ave., Buffalo; 331-3954 or tipicocoffee.com

With its house-made coconut milk (try it in a cold brew or iced chai), patterned tin ceiling, breezy storefront, and, of course, avocado toast, Tipico is everything you want in a circa-2018 coffee shop. Yes, it is stylish, and, yes, you will see many a millennial working on a laptop here, but Tipico has the substance to back up the style with great food focusing on breakfast, savory toasts and A+ americanos, lattes, and more. The style may be reminiscent of New York City but the friendly attitude and ample seating are pure Buffalo.

 

Best coffee shop (northtowns)

Steamworks Coffee Roasters

51 Canal St., Lockport; 727-0701 or steamworkscoffee.net

Not just your morning cup of joe, Steamworks searches out some of the best green beans from around the world, then roasts small batches in-house. With a solid philosophy of the better the ingredients and process, the better the end result, Steamworks crafts a superior cup of pour-over coffee. The store is also a big part of the community, hosting musical acts, bike rides, and pop-up coffee events throughout the region.

 

Best coffeeshop (southtowns)

Taste

634 Main St., East Aurora; 655-1874 or tasteofea.com

Long-standing quality coffee shops occupy the same space as beloved diners or neighborhood bars—the food is always good, the atmosphere is always comfortable, and when planning where to go, they’re always on the list of possibilities. A fixture on East Aurora’s Main street with indoor and outdoor seating and steaming cup of coffee sign, Taste specializes in espresso drinks, breakfast items, salads, and sandwiches. Try a Belgian waffle, Sunrise Benedict (a veggie take on the classic), or breakfast burrito for brunch. Lunch offerings include the Cali Dreamer (a wrap with avocado, corn, black beans, and chipotle hummus), paninis, a chicken Caesar salad wrap, quesadillas, and grilled cheese. Taste also features nut milks made by local purveyor Elmhurst Dairy, for those eschewing animal products or looking to try something new.

 

Best basic burger (city)

Lucky Day Whiskey Bar

320 Pearl St., Buffalo; 322-0547 or luckydaywhiskeybar.com

Lucky Day’s Thrasher Burger is only $5. And if you want one, you’re going to have to sit on a stool (or at a table) in the sexy-chic, dimly lit surrounds of downtown’s newest (and coolest) whiskey bar, Lucky Day. Made in-house with a grind just different enough to set it apart from your average burger (beef and bacon!), at $5, the Thrasher would be tough to beat even if it weren’t good, but it is. It really is. We’ll take ours with a shot (or two) and a beer. Thanks!

 

Best basic burger (northtowns)

>>> Tie

Grover’s Bar & Grill

9160 Transit Rd., East Amherst; 636-1803

Buffalo BrewPub

6861 Main St., Williamsville; 632-0552 or buffalobrewpub.com

Formerly Grover Cleveland’s hunting lodge, Grover’s is famous for its tasty, behemoth burgers comprising twelve ounces of ninety percent lean certified Angus beef. Especially hungry guests can order the Bruiser—an oversized certified Angus ground beef patty with grilled onions and crumbled blue cheese on a buttered roll. Plus, the prices are small, the portions are huge, and there’s a full, well-stocked bar. Carnivores, rejoice.
As the oldest brewpub in New York State, the Buffalo Brewpub has been slinging suds and bar food since 1986. The fourteen-item burger menu includes a ten ounce Angus beef  that comes with your choice of sides. It’s a great match for a cold one from the pub’s three-dozen-plus tap selection.

 

Best basic burger (southtowns)

Stack Burger

174 Orchard Park Rd., West Seneca; 288-8204 or stackburgerny.com

Every fast food joint can offer single burgers with an order of fries for under ten bucks, but that’s where the similarity ends. At Stack Burger, the burgers are fresh and made to order, the fries are handcut, and there are some irresistable oddities on the menu— like a deep-fried PB&J (for dessert).

 

Best gourmet burger (city)

Allen Burger Venture (ABV)

175 Allen St., Buffalo; 768-0386 or allenburgerventure.com

There’s a burger for everyone at ABV, with an assortment of styles to choose from and an array of patties sure to please veg-heads and paleo peeps alike. But no matter what you order, come hungry, because these burgers are huge. So huge, in fact, they typically require a fork and a steak knife. Don’t worry, the staff knows and typically makes sure customers have one of each!

 

Best gourmet burger (northtowns)

Griffon Gastropub

810 Center St., Lewiston; 405-7291 or thegriffonpub.com

The fourth and newest edition of Griffon Gastropubs is housed in a beautifully renovated building on Center Street in Lewiston where the iconic Clarkson House fed diners for decades. The Griffon House Burger is a meaty, decadent treat starting with eight ounces of house-ground short ribs, chuck, and sirloin grilled how you like it, then topped with an herbed bone marrow spread, applewood smoked bacon, and Gruyere cheese. A smattering of sautéed forest mushrooms and arugula is a nod toward plant-type things.

 

Best gourmet burger (southtowns)

Juicy Burger Bar

1 Buffalo St., Hamburg; 648.3200 or juicyburgerbar.com

PHOTO BY KC KRATT

 

Juicy grew such a large following so quickly, that it tripled (maybe even quadrupled) in size, with a huge remodel/refresh a hot minute later. Now it’s pumping out scratchmade burgers as fast as Hamburgians can eat them. We usually stick to the classics, but the variety of tempting menu options doesn’t make that an easy task.

 

Best beef on ‘weck (city)

Eckl’s

703 Seneca St., Buffalo; 331-3242 or eckls.com

Eckl’s is a classic Buffalo joint and its beef on ’weck has been well regarded since it opened its doors in 1934. After a brief shuttering in 2016, its name and fare continue to enchant beloved regulars and new fans, both at its original location in OP and at its newborn (and fancier) second location in Larkin Square. Hand-carved the old fashioned way, there’s a reason this iteration of Buffalo’s timeless roast beef sandwich was a standout for Roadfood’s Jane and Michael Stern.

 

Best beef on ‘weck (northtowns)

>>> Tie

Charlie the Butcher

Multiple locations; charliethebutcher.com

PHOTO BY jim bush

 

How many travelers stop by the Charlie the Butcher near the airport on their way in or out of Buffalo? Based on the anecdotes we’ve heard, the answer is a lot. And who can blame them? A taste of home on the way in or out of town is a solid move we fully support. But with a handful of other CtBs sprinkled across the region, it seems this is the go-to not just for those who know they will miss (or are missing) Buffalo, but also for those of us who know just how good we’ve got it.

 

The Glen Park Tavern

5507 Main St, Buffalo; 626-9333 or glenparktavernbuffalo.com

On the other hand, what could be better than a neighborhood tavern that caters to a fathful crowd of regulars who have come to rely on consistently excellent pub fare, including a stellar beef on ’weck? That’s the appeal of Glen Park Tavern, which now features a designated carving station.

 

Best beef on ‘weck (southtowns)

Bar-Bill Tavern

185 Main St., East Aurora; 652-7959 or barbill.com

The indomitable chicken wing powerhouse of East Aurora takes attention to detail to new heights in all regards, including its very craveable beef on ’weck sammie. Carved to order with dazzling efficiency, Bar-Bill’s beef on ’weck can stand alone or function as the ideal complement to a single order of medium wings, both split with a dining companion.

 

Best grilled cheese

>>> Tie

Melting Point

244 Allen St., Buffalo; 768-0426 or buffalomeltingpoint.com

 

lait Cru Brasserie

346 Connecticut St., Buffalo; 462-4100 or laitcrubrasserie.com

A restaurant that specializes in cheese and another that specializes in grilled cheese can both be expected to deliver well-executed grilled cheese sandwiches. Although Melting Point and Lait Cru live up to those expectations, they provide distinctly different experiences. Melting Point offers a large and comprehensive sandwich-based menu, while Lait Cru’s  grilled cheese is part of a French-inspired fine dining program. Cheese-lovers should rejoice that both of these delicious options exist.

 

Best tacos (city)

>>> Tie

Casa Azul

128 Genesee St., Buffalo; 331-3869 or casaazulbuffalo.com

Casa Azul combines the ambiance of a hip new downtown hotspot with an almost beach-y flair: blue walls, casual seating, counter service, streamlined menu, and ample margaritas and Coronas. But the tacos, not their environment, are the true stars of the show. All the basics are covered—shrimp, carne asada, fried fish, and a vegetarian squash mixture—as well as some more adventurous choices like braised goat, or, in a non-taco choice, guacamole with cricket brittle.  Chef Vincenza (Zina) Lapi's respect for tradition is enlivened with frequent dashes of creativity and innovation.

 

Lloyd Taco Factory

1503 Hertel Ave, Buffalo; 863-9781 or whereslloyd.com

Beloved by many Buffalonians from its years as a food truck-only operation, Lloyd—its trucks and its Taco Factory—does Mexican the way Americans have grown to love it, but better, with fresh and often local ingredients, brightly flavored pickled veggies, high-quality sauces and tortillas, and zero neon-orange cheese. At the stationary city location on Hertel Avenue, all the truck favorites, such as braised beef, slow-roasted pork, and local black beans, are on the menu, but you can also try a taco with buttermilk fried chicken or fried organic tofu with peanut sauce. Never fear, the famous nachos and burrito bowls are available as well, along with Lloyd’s highly regarded margaritas.

 

Best tacos (northtowns)

La Divina Dos

4125 Transit Rd., Williamsville; 580-7674 or ladivinados.com

The concept is the same as at the original (and beloved) La Divina in Kenmore:  order your choice of taco (or quesadilla, nachos, etc.), add sauces and garnishes at the toppings bar, including salsas, sauces, chopped cilantro, and limes, and tuck in. You’ll find your basic ground beef taco, but be brave and try the lengua (beef tongue), which melts in your mouth. The asada and the barbacoa tacos are authentic bites you might find at taco stands in any Mexican city.

 

Best tacos (southtowns)

Mexico City

5569 Camp Rd., Hamburg; 202-1397 or mexicocityhamburg.com

Located in a can’t-miss bright-orange building en route to the Village of Hamburg, this taco hotspot has some of the best tortillas around, not to mention the fillings and salsas, which score points for quality and for authenticity. Try the carne asada, the al pastor, or, for a great vegetarian (though not vegan) choice, the chile renello; or, if you’re feeling like something out of what Americans would consider the ordinary, try the chapulin (grasshopper), cactus, and beef tongue. Tacos are served either Mexican style (with onions, cilantro, and salsa) or Texan style (with lettuce, tomato, sour cream and cheese). You know that Mexican style is the best, right? Especially with this excellent salsa verde, made from tomatillos instead of tomatoes, for that true taqueria flavor.

 

Best Buffalo-style pizza (city)    

>>> Tie

Lovejoy Pizza

Multiple locations; lovejoypizza.com

La Nova     

Multiple locations; lanova.com

An old classic and a hungry upstart, that’s how we’d classify these two contenders for a title no one wants to lose. It’s hard to argue with La Nova, as it’s been delivering Buffalo-style ‘za to area homes since delivery was born. We prefer the dine-in La Nova experience, but you can’t beat a piping hot pie from this venerable West Side establishment. And over here in the right corner, we have the East Side’s Lovejoy Pizza, whose owner still makes pies and wings all day, who never skimps on quality or labor, whose ‘za sings whether its fresh outta the oven or taking a twenty-minute trip home on the passenger seat of your car. Founded in 2012, they may not seem like upstarts to an outsider, but when you’re trying to earn a place among the Buffalo pizza contenders, you gotta play the long game.

 

Best Buffalo-style pizza (northtowns)

>>> Tie

Bocce Club Pizza

4175 Bailey Ave., Buffalo; 833-1344 or bocceclubpizza.com

Bocce Club slice

Photo by kc kratt

 

Franco’s pizza

1153 Kenmore Ave., Buffalo; 427-6848 or francospizza.com

As far as we’re concerned, Bocce not only invented Buffalo-style pizza, but perfected it. And they’ve stayed on their game all this time, which is not an easy thing to do. When some poor out-of-town sap asks you what Buffalo pizza is, point ’em at the internet. First so they can Google “cup and char,” but primarily for the purpose of having a Bocce pie shipped to their door. In a city with a pizza origin story like this, it’s no wonder Domino’s failed in our market. Another Buffalo-style stalwart, Franco’s, has become the go-to pizza choice for so many locals. With five locations, capable delivery service, decent wings, and over twenty specialty pizzas on offer, Franco’s quality and reliability has not diminished with its growth.

 

Best Buffalo-style pizza (southtowns)

Imperial Pizza

1035 Abbott Rd., Buffalo; 825-3636 or imperialpizzabuffalo.com

Imperial is undergoing an extensive refresh, and for that we are eternally grateful. It looks like the days of driving from South Buffalo with a piping hot “cheese pull” stretched between our mouths and our slice-holding right hand while steering only with our left are finally coming to an end, as a 7,000 square feet expansion is underway for one of our all-time favorite pizza joints. No more scalding hot, single handed-while-driving pizza consumption for us, soon there will be plenty of room to tuck into one of Buffalo’s best pies on the spot.

 

Best thin crust pizza, (city)

Romeo & Juliet’s

Multiple locations; rjcaffe.com

PHOTO BY KC KRATT

 

R&J beat the crowds and the cool kids to thin-crust pizza rage decades ago. As a bakery, R&J has a passion for all things dough-related and its dedication to a quality thin-crust pizza is something we can all get behind. Go classic margherita or play around a bit; just be sure to order an extra one if you expect to take some home.

 

Best thin crust pizza (northtowns)

>>> Tie

Jay’s Artisan Pizza

2872 Delaware Ave., Kenmore; 322-1704 or jaysartisan.com

Rocco’s Wood Fired pizza

5433 Transit Rd., Williamsville; 247-5272 or roccoswoodfiredpizza.com

News that the OG Wood Fire Pizza truck retired might bum you out, but thank goodness it’s because its owners have opened a permanent location in Kenmore, Jay’s. True-to-style thin crust pizzas are what Jay’s is known for, and rightfully so, but the local pizza guru’s obsessive effort to perfect a Detroit-style pizza means some of those are often available as well. Get it to go or stay and have dinner!
   Five Italian guys who know great food founded Rocco’s in 2011. Their motto: “It’s the wood that makes it good.” Two massive brick ovens loaded with burning cordwood ensure well-browned crusts on the wide array of excellent pizzas Rocco’s offers. Bonus: crispy chicken wings and thighs are another delicious wood-roasted specialty here.

 

Best thin crust pizza (southtowns)

Elm Street Bakery

72 Elm St., East Aurora;  652-4720 or elmstreetbakery.com

We love the baked goods at Elm Street, and its lunch program is adorable and efficient, but one of the things that brings East Aurora residents back again and again is the pizza that comes out of its mammoth wood fired oven. While the margherita is the standard by which all pizza anywhere should be judged, we suggest you venture toward the more creative aspects of the ESB pizza menu—the bacon pizza with goat cheese and the market green pizza (be sure to add an egg), are our faves.

 

Best Middle Eastern/Mediterranean (city)

>>> Tie

Shish Kabob Express

1207 Hertel Ave., Buffalo; 447-1207 or shishkabobexpress.com

House of Hummus

1150 Hertel Ave., Buffalo; 322-6484 or houseofhummusbuffalo.com

Together, these two eateries comprise a little falafel district on Hertel Ave. Both are excellent in their own ways, but don’t miss the intensely seasoned shawarma meat piled high on rotating spits served on samoon bread at Shish Kabob Express. And if you’re feeling nontraditional, dive into House of Hummus’s oddly satisfying falafel “cheesesteak” hoagie.

 

Best Middle Eastern/Mediterranean (northtowns)    

The 755 Restaurant & Lounge

755 West Market St., Niagara Falls; 205-8969 or 755westmarket.com

Take a large group with you and order The Feast, a meal replete with conscientious service and a sampling of everything we love to eat here: falafel, fried cauliflower and eggplant, hummus, baba ganoush, your choice of tabouli or fatoush, and a selection from assorted meat offerings. We’re convinced you’ll love this family-owned and operated Niagara Falls restaurant as much as we do.

 

Best Middle Eastern/Mediterranean (southtowns)

Rachel’s Mediterranean

3860 McKinley Pkwy., Hamburg; 464-3857 or eatrachels.com

Simple, fresh and fast: these are the three imperatives that have made Rachel’s so succssful. For delicious souvlakis, gyros, falafel, salads, and more, as well as easy online and app ordering—Rachel’s is the place. It’s perfect for those who don’t have much time, but still want a healthy, tasty lunch.

 

Best pho (city)

99 Fast Food Vietnamese Restaurant

3398 Bailey Ave., Buffalo; 836-6058 or 99fastfood.com

There are other really great Vietnamese/Thai places in town, and lots of people have favorites they swear by, but it’s hard to argue that anyone does pho better than 99. That’s why, on cold days, you can find the booths crammed with chefs and restaurant folks, as well as a Thai and Vietnamese diners. The broth here is what’s unmistakably superior. It’s delicately balanced but also packed with all of the healing and soothing benefits “bone broth” connotes. Go for the raw beef tendon (extra meat is available for $1 incremental upcharges) and steam away your allergies, head colds, and maybe a worry or two.

 

Best pho (suburbs)

Red Pepper Chinese and Vietnamese Restaurant

3910 Maple Rd., Amherst; 831-3878 or redpepperbuffalo.com

PHOTO BY nancy j. parisi

 

Long established, with crowds of regulars, Red Pepper might be best known for its extensive list of American Chinese favorites. But its small menu of Vietnamese specialties should not be overlooked. Big bowls of clear broth loaded with noodles and studded with sliced beef are a delight to slurp. Pair them with slim Vietnamese spring rolls—the best in town—and you’ll forget all about that sweet and sour chicken you came for.

 

Best ramen

Sato Ramen

Multiple locations; satorestaurantgroup.com

PHOTO BY KC KRATT

 

The Sato dynasty is now made up of three unique locations, the fast casual Sato Ramen near UB’s south campus, the original location on Elmwood Avenue with a slick dining room and broad menu, and the smash hit izakaya, Sato Brewpub, located in the Dun Building on Pearl Street. We love the Shio Butter ramen with pork and chicken broth brightened by lemon, the Vegan Green Curry ramen with coconut milk, and even the Buffalo Chicken ramen. Each Sato establishment has a slightly different ramen menu, so be sure to look online if one of these piques your interest. There are plenty of other hits on their menus as well, but working your way through the ramen menu is a good place to start.

 

Best french fries (city)

>>> Tie

Jim’s Steakout

Multiple locations; jimssteakout.com

Soho Buffalo

64 Chippewa St., Buffalo; 856-7646 or sohobarbuffalo.com

Fancy fries served with shaved truffles are fine. But it’s also great to get down and dirty on a big heap of Jim’s fries at 2 a.m. like any self-respecting Buffalonian (especially if there’s a chicken finger sub in the mix (blue cheese and mayo, no oil). Get ‘em to go or eat ‘em while surrounded by other slightly intoxicated humans, whatever works for you. Just remember they’re so damn hot they need at least five minutes to cool—finish off the sub while you’re waiting.

For a slightly elevated fry experience, but also perfectly suited for barfly noshers, Soho offers crispy, hand-cut fries until 11 p.m. or midnight, depending on the night.

 

Best french fries (northtowns)

Frank Gourmet Hot Dogs

Multiple locations; findfranknow.com

Last year, the boys from Frank added a pop-up at Downtown’s Expo Market to their repertoire. This year they’ve expanded to their own stand-alone location on Kenmore Avenue. Frank’s fries are like heaven—perfectly cut, par-cooked with love, and finished in a piping hot fryer to a crispy shade of golden brown. You could desecrate them with ketchup, but we suggest you order one of Frank’s custom sauces on the side instead. Warning: you’ll be ruined for other fries … forever.

 

Best french fries (southtowns)

Connors Hotdog Stand

8905 Lake Shore Rd., Angola; 459-1257 or connorshotdogstand.com

Connors is only open during the warm weather months, when Angola’s beach is vying for its own version of The Jersey Shore, so the window of opportunity for Connors french fry consumption is limited. That might be part of what makes them so good. That and the fact that they’re hand-cut from fresh potatoes every day. Hunched over a picnic table under the covered outdoor dining area, you take temporary relief from the sun while teenagers goof around in the parking lot and the sound of motorboat engines cascades over the tops of beachfront houses and into your ears. Summer is fleeting. Eat good fries outdoors while you can.

 

Best gluten free (city)

>>> Tie

Feature Meals

598 Main St., Buffalo; 845-7060 or featuremeals.com

Sun Cuisines

1989 Niagara St, Buffalo; 447-0202 or suncuisines.com

Take meals to go, dine in-house, or order enough meal prep to get you through the week, this brightly decorated eatery on the corner of Chippewa and Main is here to meet all of your dietary allergies, restrictions, and preferences with healthy freshmade meals just for you. With only a singular exception (BreadHive bagels are featured on the breakfast menu) all of Feature Meals’  food is gluten free, from the breadcrumbs in the meatloaf to the substitution of liquid aminos for soy sauce, so go ahead and get your grub on!

Meanwhile, at Sun Cuisines, gluten free has always been in style, as you’d expect from a restaurant with so much great sushi on offer. But that’s not the only health-related reason we love Sun; its black rice menu adds delicious nutritional benefits, upping the ante on an already stellar gluten-free game.

 

Best gluten free (northtowns)

Fresh Catch Poke Co.

5933 Main St., Williamsville; 271-7653 or freshcatchpoke.com

We know most gluten free-leaning diners can find their way around any menu just fine, but it’s especially easy with Williamsville rice and protein-centric poke mecca, Fresh Catch. Here clear menu labeling combined with a super fresh menu make avoiding gluten not just easy but healthy, delicious, and satisfying.

 

Best gluten-free (southtowns)

Sweet Pea Bakery

One Buffalo St., Hamburg; 202-1192 or sweetpeabakerywny.com

The breakfast, lunch, and cake menus here would be tempting for anyone,  regardless of gluten preferences, but, from what we’ve heard, the cakes are getting the raves. Stop in for a sandwich or panini; follow it up with a Red Velvet cupcake.

 

Best vegan options (city)

Betty’s

370 Virginia St., Buffalo; 362-0633 or bettysbuffalo.com

Known for years as a solid choice for vegans and vegetarians with its tofu scramble brunch and many healthy options for breakfast (soy yogurt is available, and a veganizeable veggie hash), lunch (try tofu peanut wrap or a barbecue pulled veggie sandwich) and dinner (polenta with roasted squash can be made vegan), Betty’s has upped its vegan game, adding grilled tofu as a protein option for its many salads (including a stellar thai noodle, my standard order) and a host of frequent dinner specials with regional flare, such as a vegan tater tot poutine and a vegan garbage plate. All menu items are clearly marked as to whether they are or can be altered to be vegan, vegetarian, gluten-free or dairy free. Opened in 2004, Betty’s is an old favorite with a menu that has evolved with the times.

 

Best vegan options (northtowns)

CoreLife Eatery

1595 Niagara Falls Blvd., Amherst; 276-0071 or corelifeeatery.com

Do you ever go to a restaurant and think: I want a kale salad, but not with that dressing, and actually not with those toppings either, and also, I wonder if I could get that with croutons? Or could I get that with chickpeas instead of chicken, and absolutely no onions? If menus are often not quite right for what you have in mind, CoreLife is your ideal destination. It features broth bowls, salads, and grain bowls with a build-your-own option for all, as well as combinations that come pre-suggested (but can still be customized). For a great vegan choice, try the sriracha ginger roasted tofu as a salad or as an ancient grains bowl, or the veggie broth bowl with mushrooms and roasted tofu. Or build your own! With plenty of hearty vegan stir-ins such as black beans, edemame and avocado, this is one health food spot where vegans will not go hungry. CoreLife features two Northtowns locations: in Amherst and Clarence.

 

Best barbecue and barbecue sides (city)

Fat Bob’s smokehouse

41 Virginia Pl., Buffalo; 887-2971 or fatbobs.com

With great sauces and efficient service, Fat Bob’s ticks a lot of boxes for diners looking for a laidback and tasty dining experience in the city. Packed full of young city dwellers, families, and travelers, the vibe here is always good. Choose a cold one from the extensive beer list, order up a pile of barbeque, and strap yourself in for a fun and chill night at one of Buffalo’s favorite old-school city joints.

 

Best barbecue (northtowns)

>>> Tie

Suzy Q's Bar-b-que  Shack

2829 Niagara St., Buffalo; 873-0757

One-eyed Jack's Smokehouse Grill

5983 S Transit Rd., Lockport; 438-5414 or oneeyedjacksbbq.com

It’s usually a positive indication that good barbecue is around when you can smell aromatic wood smoke outside of the restaurant—as you will at Suzy Q’s. Huge sandwiches are piled high with barbecued meat that’s been lightly kissed by that wood smoke and dressed with a tangy complementing sauce. Ribs might have bit more chew than you are used to, but cooking them just shy of falling off the bone is a barbecue law that’s respected by true pitmasters.

Travel northeast and you’ll find the gang’s all here at Jack’s, including succulent pulled pork, dry-rubbed brisket, and smoked chicken wings (for something a little left of classic). It’s easy to get overfull at Jack’s, but save room for dessert.

 

Best barbecue (southtowns)

BW's Smokin' Barrels Barbecue

5007 Lake Ave, Buffalo; 824-7455 or bwbbq.com

Fun decor, homemade sauces, and a selection of smoked and grilled meats that have earned the loyalty of a large fan base are among the reasons BW’s reigns supreme in the Southtowns. There’s even a brunch, though it’s only available January–June. Fan tip: try the ribs.

 

Best barbecue sides (northtowns)

Smoke on the Water

77 Young St., Tonawanda, 692-4227 or sotw77.com

PHOTO BY KC KRATT

 

Tater tots are robed in nacho cheese and dotted with hot sauce. Salty, smoky baked beans make the acquaintance of fruits and veggies via mandarin oranges and collard greens. Brussels sprouts arrive shining with maple syrup and butter. Even the basic French fry gets fancied up with a dusting of Creole VooDoo powder. Whatever sides you’re used to getting at a barbecue joint, Smoke on the Water adds its own playful twist in surprisingly delicious ways.

 

Best bagel (city)

>>> Tie

Breadhive

402 Connecticut St., Buffalo; 980-5623 or breadhive.com

Bagel Jay’s

Multiple locations, bageljays.com

While Breadhive’s many delights—exceptional bread, great sandwiches, desserts, canned wine, and local beer on tap—extend far beyond its bagel selection, unless you are not a fan of sourdough, these are the best bagels in town. Try one toasted with cream cheese, add tomato or lox, a white bean spread for the vegans, or some local goat cheese. The bagels are also excellent vehicles for breakfast sandwiches made with tofu scramble, eggs, and more.

Traditional New York-style bagels in a wide variety of styles (seeded, seasoned, rye, pumpernickel, and more) are available in Buffalo thanks to Jay Gershberg, who cofounded another iteration of the business in 1976 and rebranded it as Bagel Jay’s in 2001.  This is the place for a bagel and schmear as you’ve always known and loved them.

 

Best bagel (northtowns)

Power City Eatery

444 Third St., Niagara Falls; 299-0124 or powercityeatery.com

They say it’s the public water that makes New York City bagels so magically delicious. Pshaw! We don’t need no stinkin’ NYC H20 to make great bagels here in WNY. PCE’s four varieties of bagels—plain, everything, sesame, and multigrain—are chewy on the inside and crisp on the outside, nothing like the sleeve of white bread circles you get in the supermarket freezer. Each are created with fresh, homemade dough, boiled, and finished in the oven. Try one with one of Power City’s homemade schmears or as backbone of its fabulous sandwiches.

 

Best hot dog (city)

Frank Gourmet Hot Dogs

Multiple locations; findfranknow.com

PHOTO BY KC KRATT

 

Frank’s has partnered with a New York State farm to develop the perfect, most delicious, healthiest hot dog around. Their custom dogs are free of hormones, nitrates, and antibiotics. At Frank’s, those dogs are nestled into scratchmade buns and covered with creative housemade toppings. These are the elements that make Frank’s dogs the best dogs we’ve ever had, and according to our poll, you feel that way, too. And guess what, dog lovers? With a new location in Kenmore, Frank’s dogs are easier to get than ever.

 

Best hot dog (suburbs)

Ted’s hot dogs

Multiple locations; tedshotdogs.com

A visit to Ted’s hot dogs is as indelible a WNY childhood memory as a stop at the Falls, and infinitely more impressive. (Sorry, Wonder of the World.) The details are key—the dogs are charcoal broiled, the hot sauce isn’t too hot, the French fry and onion ring orders are enormous, and, of course, there’s the Loganberry. And don’t ignore the burgers and chicken sandwiches, or the simple joy of watching your food being prepared by employees who are pleasant and cheerful. A rarity, that.

 

Best classic wings (city)

>>> Tie

Kelly’s Korner

2526 Delaware Ave., Buffalo; 877-9466

the Lenox Grill

140 North St., Buffalo; 884-1700 or lenoxgrill.com

We’ve done exhaustive wing research, not just for our wing issue a few years back, but ongoing. After all, the wing is a Buffalo “thing,” and, therefore, local media are expected to stay on top of all things wing. There are a lot of great places to eat wings in WNY for sure, and we know that everyone has their favorites and uses their own sets of criteria. But what we want are really good wings, every time, no matter who’s ordering or who is in the kitchen—and Kelly’s delivers. You don’t have to ask for extra crispy or do somersaults for the waitstaff, just order the heat level you like and enjoy. (Pro tip: the beef on ’weck is pretty great, too.)

At Lenox Grill, wing lovers can enjoy excellent wings in their choices of seven different styles with the added bonus of access to the top selection of bottled beers in town. This killer combo is part of what makes Lenox such a serious contender. It’s also one of Allentown’s most convivial hangouts —with a fun, lively crowd at the bar most nights.

 

Best wings (northtowns)

>>> Tie

Duff’s Famous Wings

Multiple locations; duffswings.com

Judi’s Lounge, Bar & Grill

2075 Military Rd., Niagara Falls; 297-5759 or judisbarandgrill.com

Duff’s is one of WNY’s all-time favorite wing spots. If a place is frequented by Food Network watchers, out-of-town visitors, lifers, and Presidents, it’s got to have its act together. Given those criteria, we declare Duff’s our favorite spot for classic medium hot wings among all the wing joints in the Northtowns. That is, with the exception of Judi’s in Niagara Falls, who ties for this category. Judi’s has its own take on the traditional Frank’s Red Hot and butter combo, one that you can’t balk at for straying from the accepted style, because it simply improves it. We don’t know what the secret is, but Judi’s wings offer a broader depth of flavor and fresh tomato-ness we just can’t live without.

 

Best wings (southtowns)

Bar-Bill tavern

185 Main St., East Aurora; 652-7959 or barbill.com

PHOTO BY KC KRATT

 

Look, they paint every wing by hand. Which means that not only is your plate arranged prettily and your wings sauced with incredible consistency, it also means that the staff are, to some extent, examining each wing before serving it. Bar-Bill has turned wing preparation from a task to a craft, and we can’t find anything but respect for that.

 

Best dessert, restaurant (city)

Las Puertas

385 Rhode Island St., Buffalo; 807-1141 or laspuertas-buffalo.com

Most Buffalonians know by now that Chef Victor Parra Gonzalez was nominated by the James Beard Foundation for Best Chef-Northeast this year on the strength of his diminutive West Side eatery, Las Puertas. What they might not realize is that Madeline Chase’s pastry program runs in lockstep, turning out the most refined, deftly-balanced desserts served in any WNY restaurant right now. You don’t need a sweet tooth to find deep satisfaction here. Dessert at Las Puertas is a truly perfect ending to one of the best meals to be had in the area.

 

Best dessert, restaurant (northtowns)

Siena

4516 Main St, Snyder; 839-3108 or siena-restaurant.com

Siena takes top honors on the strength of their epic DIY cannoli set. When they serve it, you can’t help but smile at the ingenuity of the setup. Diners are provided with a small piping bag, allowing them to fill the pastry tubes as they see fit, ensuring maximum crispiness. An array of toppings allows for more creative choices, making this especially clever for a large group.

 

Best dessert, restaurant (southtowns)

Elm Street Bakery

72 Elm St., East Aurora;  652-4720 or elmstreetbakery.com

As befits a restaurant where baking is the prime directive, ESB does not just have a pastry chef, it has a pastry team. Expect excellence, from the pies, cookies, and doughnuts in the pastry case to the plated desserts offered at dinner.

 

Best doughnut (city)

>>> Tie

Public Espresso + Coffee

Lafayette Hotel, 391 Washington St., Buffalo; 367-9971 or publicespressoandcoffee.com

Fry Baby Donut Company

336 South Elmwood Avenue, Buffalo; 783-7837 or facebook.com/frybb/

You wouldn’t think it would be hard to compare two donut places to one another, but Public Espresso + Coffee and Fry Baby couldn’t be more different. Public’s quiet, minimal, uptown vibe and drool-inducing menu of baked goods requires even more reverence when considering its Friday cruller special (you say croo-ler, I say cruh-ller). Prepared by esteemed baker Lucy Levere, upon first bite of the ethereally delicate confection you’ll find you’ve closed your eyes to ward off any distractions from what can only be likened to a religious experience. Over in Allentown at Fry Baby, donut-seekers will find dozens of massive neon-frosted vegan fry cakes flying out a tiny, pastel-drenched hole-in the-wall in the hands of pastry-starved vegans at lighting speed. But omnivores should feel welcome, too, because a good doughnut is a good doughnut.

 

Best doughnut (northtowns)

Paula’s Donuts

Multiple locations; paulasdonuts.com

If Alton Brown loves Paula’s Donuts, who are you to argue? We know you won’t. Because you’re from Buffalo, and here in Buffalo, we loved her as one of our own long before she caught the eye of food celebrities. Brown’s endorsement does make us feel justified in our hopeless addiction to Paula’s—our need to hoover the icing-coated peanut crumbles from the bottom of the box, to leave our brown bag lunch in the fridge until tomorrow while we polish off two (yeah, we said it) sour cream glazed old fashioneds in its place, to pretend that we only bought twelve doughnuts instead of the baker’s dozen because we ate the thirteenth one in the car on our way to the party. No, Alton, you didn’t tell us anything we didn’t already know, but you did make us feel better about it.

 

Best doughnut (southtowns)

Donut Kraze

406 Dingens St., Buffalo; 824-4527 or donutkrazebuffalo.com

If doughnut shops should be measured by their old-fashioned sour cream, Donut Kraze might take top honors. It’s deeply browned, extra craggy, and crunchy, with a restrained glaze that doesn’t require a tall glass of milk to recover from. And that’s just one of a solid lineup of donuts that includes the standards along with unique varieties like peanut butter and jelly, strawberry cheesecake, and blueberry crumble.

 

Best cake (city)

Fairy Cakes

289 Parkside Ave., Buffalo; 688-0361 or fairycakesbuffalo.com

Cupcakes are the new cake in bakeries across the US; Buffalo is no exception to this trend. The adorable little confections rise in pyramids at weddings and other formal occasions, fill trays at kids’ parties, and disappear from breakrooms everywhere. Fairy Cakes is cupcake central for many here, with good reason. The flavors range from the expected (S’mores, Brownie Batter, Key Lime) to “what?!” (Pancake/Bacon, Buffalo Hot Wing, and Lucky Charms come to mind.) There are infinite customized options, enough to suit even the most outlandish theme party.

 

Best cake (northtowns)

>>> Tie

Dessert Deli

716 Maple Rd., Williamsville; 689-2115  or dessertdelibakery.com

Muscoreil's Fine Desserts & Gourmet Cakes

3960 Niagara Falls Blvd.; 692-9081 or muscoreils.com

These two veterans of the local sweets scene consistently deliver top-notch cakes, tarts, cookies, and other confections. It would take pages to describe the delicious offerings from both, so let’s just focus on cakes. A glance at Muscoreil’s website cake gallery shows cutesy creations like Stanley Cup cakes, Volkswagon bug cakes, and lots of cakes in the shapes of beloved pets, but the wedding cakes are breathtakingly elegant. It’s hard to believe that any other bakery could  produce work at this level.

But then,  there’s Dessert Deli, with a website displaying an equal array of stunning confections. Spree staffers have veen lucky enough to sample wares from both these bakeries and we have wisely decided not to pick a favorite.

 

Best ice cream shop (city)

Churn Soft Serve

1501 Hertel Ave., Buffalo; 863-9781 or churnsoftserve.com

Yes, it might be limited to soft serve, but doing only one thing has its advantage, and Churn does it extremely well. Ice cream made from real whole milk (from Pittsford Dairy) and not some unholy mix of skim milk, thickeners, emulsifiers, and whipped air, is noticeably richer and creamier in terms of flavor and mouthfeel. Chef Jen Boye, who is no stranger to the Best Of awards in her own right, recently joined the team and is finding ways to make great soft serve even better.

 

Best ice cream shop (northtowns)

Lake Effect Artisan Ice Cream

Multiple locations; lakeeffecticecream.com

LEIC has become synonymous with Buffalo. It’s everywhere, and we aren’t complaining. People love its extensive menu of local-centric custom flavors (Paula’s Glazed Donut and Revolution Coffee flavors, we’re looking at you!), kooky sundaes, freezie pops, ice cream cakes, and more. We especially love its original location in Lockport, which overlooks the canal and has plenty of places to sit inside and out, but, to be honest, we’ll take Lake Effect Ice Cream anyway we can get it.

 

Best ice cream shop (southtowns)

Fran-Ceil Custard

3411 South Park Ave., Blasdell; franceilcustard.com

Handmade, old-fashioned, real deal custard can be found at Fran-Ceil’s, just off South Park Avenue. Only two or three other spots in all of WNY are making custom custard creations from scratch—most places are using prefab stuff that’s low on dairy and high on chemical additives. We love Fran-Ceil’s banana custard. And the tangerine. And the chocolate. And the pistachio … we digress. Once you’ve had the custard at Fran-Ceil’s, you’ll realize it’s impossible to confuse it with anything else, In fact you may be unwilling to eat any other “soft serve” ever again. We wouldn’t blame you.

 

Best juicery

>>> Tie

Squeeze Juicery

Multiple locations; squeezejuicerybuffalo.com

PHOTO BY KC KRATT

 

Ashker's

Multiple locations; ashkersbuffalo.com

Sometimes it’s about more than just juice: now with three locations, Ashker’s offers a surprisingly varied and creative menu featuring—in addition to fresh juices and smoothies—salads, grilled sandwiches, desserts, and daily specials. Ashker’s also uses quality ingredients, local when available. Sometimes, a juicery is mainly about the juice, as with Squeeze. Though Squeeze does offer wraps, salads,  and granola bowls, depending on location, its juice and smoothie menu is formidable, including fruit, green, citrus, root, nut milk, and shots, among other categories. If you can’t find a juice you like at Squeeze, you probably don’t like juice.

 

Best new restaurant

Swan Street Diner

700 Swan St., Buffalo; 768-1823 or swanstreetdiner.com

PHOTO BY eric frick

 

Place a reimagined diner inside a restored thirties-era dining car, position it carefully on the grounds of a rehabilitated neighborhood, add a mug of black coffee with a hot-from-the-fryer doughnut chaser and you’ll have Western New York’s Best New Restaurant. A partnership between comfort food-enthusiast Amanda Amico (Amy’s Food Truck) and Harry Zemsky (Hydraulic Hearth), Swan Street Diner offers homey classics (like chicken pot pie) and classical classics (like a tarragon-laced French-style omelet) at family-friendly prices for breakfast and lunch every day of the week. Just think, this means that if you are very lucky, you can enjoy two-thirds of your weekly meals at this beautiful little bastion of kind service and good food in the heart of Larkinville.

 

Best new restaurant (suburbs)

This Little Pig

4401 Transit Rd., Williamsville; 580-7872 or thislittlepigeats.com

PHOTO BY KC KRATT

 

This Little Pig’s been charming diners only since mid-summer 2017, but it already has a strong following. The reason: this cozy locally-owned-and-operated restaurant is doing so many things right. Housemade pastas, sauces and condiments, sausages, and pizza/bread doughs all play a role in virtually every dish on the menu. As a family-driven business with owners working alongside relatives daily, This Little Pig’s mindfulness of the diner’s experience far exceeds its nearby corporate competition.

 

Best restaurant for a special occasion (city)

Ristorante Lombardo

1198 Hertel Ave.,

Buffalo; 873-4291 or ristorantelombardo.com

Ristorante Lombardo checks all the boxes for the ideal evening out. From the valet to the bartender to the waitstaff, there is acute—but not overbearing—attention to your needs. Hearty Northern Italian dishes are well composed and sure to please most palates. And a stellar wine menu offers standouts at multiple price points. So assemble your celebratory crew, and make a reservation; it’s a lock that no one will leave disappointed.

 

Best restaurant for special occasion (northtowns)

Salvatore’s Italian Gardens

6461 Transit Rd., Depew; 456-4097 or salvatoreshospitality.com

When a large group—family or otherwise—needs to get together for great food in a fun place with excellent service, there are just a few options, especially when there are ten or more people. Salvatore’s has long been one of the most reliable of these options, with private dining and the ability to accommodate large groups seamlessly. You’ll feel special here, and so will your loved ones.

 

Best restaurant for special occasion (southtowns)

The Grange Community Kitchen

22 Main St., Hamburg; 648-0022 or grangecommunitykitchen.com

It’s hard to successfully convey how The Grange gets so many little things right, but it just does. By day the bustling and casual eatery is sunlit and cheerful; by night it’s romantic and understated. Ask for a corner table, order a bottle of wine, and concentrate on your dining companion. Or book the large community table for a jubilant, glass-clinking feast with seven of your closest friends. No matter what the occasion, The Grange is the place to celebrate it.

 

Best decor (city)

>>> Tie

Rowhouse Bakery and Restaurant

483 Delaware Ave., Buffalo; 500-2253 or rowhousebuffalo.com

Patina 250

250 Delaware Ave., Buffalo; 290-0600 or patinagroup.com/patina-250

Just a few blocks from each other on Delaware Avenue, these two restaurants demonstrate very different architecture and aesthetic priorities, but both achieve the type of ambiance that leads diners to forget their appetites and wander about in admiration. Rowhouse  does this through its use of a spectacular, multileveled combination of three historic townhouses. Patina 250 does this through its thoughtful and hyperlocal art installations.

 

Best décor (northtowns)

Sinatra’s

945 Kenmore Ave., Kenmore; 877-9419, or sinatraswny.com

When Sinatra’s announced its move, we could not have envisioned the Sinatra’s of today. While keeping to its roots, the new location (just across the street from its original location) is elegant, timeless, and exquisitely appointed thanks to the efforts of designer Michael P of Hertel Avenue’s design firm, room. Finally, Sinatra’s appearance and vibe matches its well-earned reputation as one of the best restaurants in Western New York.

 

Best decor (southowns)

Carte Blanche

61 Buffalo St., Hamburg; 649-2101 or carteblanchehamburg.com

The simple but smart and meorable touches here include a main bar and first floor dining room smartly dressed in warm wood and natural elements, including suspended branches and a burbling fountain. The overall feel is sleek but warm, homey but never cluttered.

 

Best chef (established)    

Adam Goetz, Craving

1472 Hertel Ave., Buffalo; 883-1675 or cravingbuffalo.com

His nickname is the “OG” for a reason. Though most know him as the owner of Craving, owner of the former Allentown eatery, Sample, and as a Nickel City Chef, Goetz has a pretty great resume that predates his return to Buffalo in the mid-aughts. But it’s okay that you don’t know it, because the people who need to, do, and they’re often on the other end of the line with questions for him about a mothballed cooking technique, breaking down an entire cow, or how to cost a menu. An early adopter of the farm-to-table movement, Goetz has been an integral and underrated part of bringing Buffalo’s food scene from the nineties into modern times, and for that we can’t thank him enough.

 

Best chef (new)

Joseph Fenush III, Toutant

437 Ellicott St., Buffalo; 342-2901 or toutantbuffalo.com

As chef de cuisine of downtown’s popular Toutant, Joseph Fenush excels at kitchen management, quality, and inventory controls for one of the busiest scratchmade kitchens in the region. But it’s his creative dexterity and inventiveness that has us really excited. We’ve featured him in the pages of Spree, with a recipe for a black pepper and strawberry tart we can’t stop thinking about, but you can taste his penchant for fermentation, interesting ingredients, and fascinating cooking techniques by ordering any of the magical vegetable plates featured on Toutant’s daily menu.

 

Best use of local ingredients (city)

Marble + Rye

112 Genesee St., Buffalo; 853-1390 or marbleandrye.net

Many Buffalo-written farm-to-table lists would overlook Marble + Rye. Why? Because here the farm relationships aren’t a marketing effort, a badge of honor, or a bro fest. You’ll find a small list of farms posted on a wall, but otherwise it’s hard to tell that chef and co-owner Michael Dimmer’s super-seasonal menu is chockablock with local fare. These fresh ingredients work in concert with his skill and vision to quietly bolster a menu of handmade pastas, impeccable desserts, memorable appetizers, and one of the best all-local handground burgers in town.

 

Best use of local ingredients (northtowns)

Trattoria Aroma

4840 North French Rd., Amherst; 688.8848 or aromagroup.com

For a lesson on how to do restaurant empires right, would-be kingpins would do well to look to WNY’s Aroma Group. For starters, all three of its fine dining venues excel in thoughtfully composed menus of Italian favorites, offer craft cocktail programs, and seat patrons in beautiful spaces. In addition, all three look to local farmers for fresh ingredients, including the newest of the bunch, Trattoria Aroma on North French. Onsite farm dinners are also offered, to further enlighten local diners about the importance of locally sourced cuisine.

 

Best use of local ingredients (southtowns)

The Grange Community Kitchen

22 Main St., Hamburg; 648-0022 or grangecommunitykitchen.com

The hardest thing about sourcing local is how to manage all winter long without losing your mind. Rowell and the team at The Grange have figured out how to do that well, with a menu that turns turnips, beets, onions, and potatoes into crave-able, worth-driving-all-the-way-to-Hamburg kinda meals. From the local lamb pita to the local beet hummus with falafel, this year we found ourselves excited about eating at The Grange in the depth of winter. Imagine the exceptional dishes they deliver during the golden days of summer and fall.

 

Best waitstaff/service

Oliver’s

2095 Delaware Ave., Buffalo; 877-9662 or oliverscuisine.com

The wait staff at Oliver’s, efficient and attentive in their long white aprons, is nearly as important to the overall experience here as the food. Servers are knowledgeable and well-equipped to counsel on wine choices, and will cheerfully discuss varietals, food pairings, and other details about every aspect of your meal.

 

Best small wine list (bottle)

Billy Club

228 Allen St., Buffalo; 331-3047 or billyclubbuffalo.com

Billy Club sees “small” as a strength. Take for example its modest Allentown location, which is minimally (though tastefully) decorated. Or examine its tight menu of select food offerings, its decisive back bar, and the tiniest, most efficient host stand you’ve ever seen. Its wine offerings are no different, despite its owners’ affection for the stuff. With under ten perfect bottles on its list, all of which are available by the glass ($8) and by the bottle ($32), it might be the smartest list in town, even if it’s one of the shortest.

 

Best large wine list (bottle)

Tempo

581 Delaware Ave., Buffalo; 885-1594 or tempobuffalo.com

Small curated wine lists are fine most of the time. But when you want to splurge, Tempo is the place. What if the occasion demands a Billecart-Salmon, Brut Rosé Mareuil-Sur-Ay? No problem. Or how about a 1998 Barola Riserva? You’ll find it here as well as some other stellar Italian choices, and, considering the quality, prices are reasonable. This is the type of wine list that’s a pleasure to peruse even if you end up having the house white.

 

Best wine list (by the glass)

Dapper Goose

491 Amherst St., Buffalo; 551-0716 or thedappergoose.com

Spree food writer Christa Seychew has stated “The wine at Dapper Goose may be its most compelling offering.” Some might argue with her there, but there’s no question that DG includes some of the most interesting wines you’ve never heard of, both in its bottle list and on its by-the-glass menu. The list changes regularly, but expect organic producers, lesser-known wine-growing areas, and great alternatives to the usual range of cabs, pinots, and chards.

 

Best local winery

Liten Buffel

8822 Pearson Rd., Middleport; litenbuffel.com

PHOTO BY KC KRATT

 

We’ve talked about Liten Buffel a lot this year, online and here in the pages of Spree. As one of the state’s only natural wineries, they’d surely garner attention no matter what, but the truth is, they’re consistently producing really drinkable, modern (read: old school) wines unlike anyone else on this side of the state. Look for their name on the menu at Ristorante Lombardo and The Dapper Goose, pick up a bottle for dinner at Gates Circle, or take a slow and pretty Sunday (or any day) drive out to Middleport for a tasting.

 

Best local distillery

Tommyrotter Distillery

500 Seneca St. #110, Buffalo; 312-1252 or tommyrotter.com

You probably already know that Tommyrotter has won a lot of attention for its gin, but did you know that attention has stretched far beyond Western New York? With distribution all over the northeastern US, Tommyrotter is taking Buffalo’s spirit boom to new heights. We recently spotted it on the shelves of several fancy Boston cocktail bars. And don’t forget that its vodka, American whisky, bourbon, and barrel-aged gin have found footholds of their own. Keep an eye on the team at Tommyrotter; they’re going for broke.

 

Best local distillery offering

Lockhouse Distillery’s Coffee Liqueur

41 Columbia St., Buffalo; 768-4898 or lockhousedistillery.com

The first distillery to open in Buffalo since Prohibition is known for its award-winning vodka and other basic spirits, but it doesn’t stop there. There has also been a series of intriguing specialty releases, including an Ibisco bitter liquer, the lovely Sakura gin, an amaro, and Revolution coffee liqueur, which is a special collaboration with Public Espresso + Coffee. We’re late to the party taking note of this intense, cold-infused spirit; it’s one of the many reasons we love Lockhouse.

 

Best craft cocktails (city)

>>> Tie

Marble + Rye

112 Genesee St., Buffalo; 853-1390 or marbleandrye.net

PHOTO BY KC KRATT

 

Vera

220 Lexington Ave., Buffalo; 551-6262 or or verabuffalo.com

Megan Lee has been assembling graceful, astute, unconventional cocktails in WNY since she first took her place at the head of Marble + Rye’s cocktail program. Not only does the vibe at this bar feel unlike anywhere else we’ve ever been for drinks, but the original concoctions on her menu are more then just noteworthy, they’re headliners. As for Vera, Buffalo’s first craft cocktail venue (we can’t believe it’s been seven years!) does not rest on its laurels. With each new menu, Vera ups its cocktail game, while the experience here remains fun and friendly.

 

Best craft cocktails (northtowns)

Lloyd Taco Factory    

5933 Main St., Williamsville; 863-9781 or wheereslloyd.com

PHOTO BY KC KRATT

 

Bar manager Yuri Polyachenko has created a fantastic bar program for Lloyd. Both its original Hertel Avenue location and its newer iteration on Main Street in Williamsville benefit from his careful stewardship. From a mind-boggling mezcal selection to frozen drinks to a daily punch special, the ’burbs now have access to a cocktail program unlike anything they’ve ever had before.

 

Best craft cocktails (southtowns)

Winfields Pub

1213 Ridge Rd., Lackawanna; 821-0700 or winfieldspub.com

Tab Daulton and son Thomas have made Winfields a destination location for anyone paying attention and a remarkable neighborhood joint for anyone lucky enough to live nearby. Chef Tab’s excellent scratchmade pub fare is complemented by Thomas’s adept cocktail skills. Drinkers will find excellent renditions of the classics, but also unique and creative originals. What are you waiting for? Call an Uber and make a night of it.

 

Best margarita (city)

Casa Azul

128 Genesee St., Buffalo; 331-3869 or casaazulbuffalo.com

Rejoice, the days of bright green slush dispensed from a machine may be coming to a close. There are now a number of restaurants in Buffalo that serve honest, well-balanced margaritas, made with fresh juice. Casa Azul offers a superb basic margarita, using Azteca Azul Blanca. Even better, these well-crafted drinks are only $5 during happy hour.

 

Best margarita (suburbs)

Arriba Tortilla

40 Riley St., East Aurora; 333-0172 or arribatortilla.com

We’ve heard that fans of this Mexican/American fusion eatery love the enchiladas and corn cakes, but also attribute their loyalty to the restaurant’s extensive margarita menu, housemade mixes, and selection of ninety-some tequilas.  Sounds reasonable to us!

 

Best local brewery (city)

Community Beer Works

15 Lafayette Ave., Buffalo; 759-4677 or communitybeerworks.com

Community Beer Works is one of the rare venues where, if its brewers make something and it sounds like a questionable combination, try it anyway, because it’s bound to be good. Other shops may attempt something as ambitious as a sour raspberry stout, a low-alcohol saison with lemongrass, or an ale brewed with English Rose tea, but more than any other brewers in the Buffalo area, Community Beer Works, or CBW, can be counted on to do it right. In addition to its great brews—and they make an IPA or a lager as well as anyone, for those who prefer the classics—CBW has also become known for the many charitable benefits held at its small West Side taproom, and for its presence at local festivals such as Pride. With new locations opening soon on the Lower West Side and in Niagara Falls, CBW continues to live up to its name.

 

Best local brewery (northtowns)

12 Gates Brewing Company

80 Earhart Dr., Williamsville; 906-6600 or 12gatesbrewing.com

Tucked away in an office park in Amherst, 12 Gates might be hard to find, but, despite that, the tasting room is always packed. And with good reason: the freshly brewed tap selections provide a range of styles that range from hoppy West Coast Style IPA and dark Coffee Porter to lighter pilsners and hefeweizen. Regular canning insures that its beers can be found in grocery stores around the area.

 

Best local brewery (southtowns)

42 North

25 Pine St., East Aurora; 805-7500 or 42northbrewing.com

Easily one of the top breweries in all of WNY, 42 North makes great beers and serves them in a spacious taproom. High risk, high reward offerings like wild saison, hazy IPA, and Russian Imperial Stouts prove that this brewery excels where others fear to tread. And with a farm-to-table kitchen, there’s mighty fine grub to go with your pint of ale.

 

Best taps (city)

>>> Tie

Colter Bay

561 Delaware Ave., Buffalo; 436-5197 or colterbaybuffalo.com

Coles

1104 Elmwood Ave., Buffalo; 886-1449 or colesbuffalo.com

It’s a Shatzel project, need we say more? Thanks to Mike and his team, Colter Bay is finally back to being somewhere people want to be, and, as we’ve come to expect from the Beer King of Buffalo, it offers a plethora of prized potables on tap. From unexpected ales to scarce sours and beyond, though every Shatzel project is known for its beer, Colter Bay’s forty-four taps might make it the jewel in the crown.

 

Best taps (northtowns)

>>> Tie

Moor Pat

78 E. Spring St., Williamsville; 810-9957 or moorpat.com

Pizza Plant

Multiple locations; pizzaplant.com

Northtowns beer-lovers have so many excellent choices now. Cofounded by Mike Shatzel, Moor Pat offers an exciting and ever-changing list of specialty microbrews. Pizza Plant has long been the beer aficionada’s go-to with its thirty-beer-long tap list and beer flights for those who want to try a few different styles.

 

Best taps (southtowns)

Aurora Brew Works

191 Main St., East Aurora; 652-2337

Being more shop than bar lends a laid back feel to Aurora Brew Works and makes for a relaxing stop before or after dining at one of East Aurora’s prime restaurants. Rare and unique beers dominate the tap list, and all are available in a range of sizes, from tastes to half and full pints. In addition to growlers, the shop stocks a great selection of craft beer in cans and bottles— the trick is resisting buying too much with impaired inhibitions.

 

Best patio (city)

>>> Tie

Hydraulic Hearth

716 Swan St., Buffalo; 248-2216 or hydraulichearth.com

Frankie Primo’s +39

51 W. Chippewa St., Buffalo; 855-3739 or frankieprimos39.com

The sprawling Larkinville beer garden attached to Hydraulic Hearth seems to find ways to improve with each passing year. Live music and an assortment of outdoor games keep beer-quaffing guests entertained for hours on end, but a new outdoor menu of affordable grilled favorites insures they’ll stay full (and perhaps standing upright), too. No surprise that the design-focused Zemsky family continues to make Larkville the place to be no matter what time of day or month of the year it might be.

 

Best outdoor patio (northtowns)

The Shores Waterfront Island Restaurant & Marina

Tonawanda Island; 693-7971 or shoreswaterfront.com

PHOTO BY ERic Frick

 

This Tonawanda casual dining spot has spectacular views of the upper Niagara River, Grand Island, and Niawanda Park. Come for the gorgeous summer sunset, stay for the laidback fun.

 

Best outdoor patio (southtowns)

The Public House on the Lake

4914 Lake Shore Rd., Hamburg; 627-5551 or publichouseonthelake.com

Technicolor Lake Erie sunsets can be enjoyed in comfort from both the enclosed and outdoor dining areas here. Live music on weekends, outdoor firepits, and a great beer selection add to the enjoyment.

 

Best new hotspot (city)

Remedy House

429 Rhode Island St., 250-7724 or facebook.com/RemedyHouseBuffalo

Opening earlier than many coffee shops at six a.m. daily, and staying open into the evening with stylish low-key cocktails and snacks, Remedy House is a neighborhood hotspot for day and night. Everything about this coffeehouse and cafe is designed with attention to detail—the wicker chairs and small marble-topped tables reminiscent of a Parisian-style cafe (or its imitators on the Upper West Side of Manhattan), the well-crafted espresso drinks, the chrome fixtures, the awning-topped sidewalk cafe, the glasses of rosé, and the spot-hitting Aperol spritz that are just what you want on a breezy, rambling night before or after a meal or a party. If you need a spot to hash out your business plan, dish about your weekend, or meet with your wedding planner (multiple such conversations have been overheard here), Remedy House is your go-to on the West Side.

 

Best new hotspot (northtowns)

Tacos, Community & Beer

6449 Transit Rd., East Amherst; 458-0380 or tcbbuffalo.com

True, the gourmet tacos are delectable and imaginative. And a wide selection of Mexican, domestic, and craft beer (and wine and cocktails) offer refreshment and variety. However, what draws you back again and again is the community. Bar-height tables with stools on either side run the length of the bar area, inviting strangers to chat and connect. Music coming from the speakers adds to the fun ambiance, without making conversation impossible. The space has a clean, airy feel, and a patio rounds out the conviviality. TCB’s middle name is “Community,” after all, and they do it right.

 

Best sports bar (city)

>>> Tie

Buffalo Riverworks

359 Ganson St., Buffalo; 342-2292 or buffaloriverworks.com

(716) Food and Sport

7 Scott St., Buffalo; 855-4716 or 716foodandsport.com

The vibes are very different at these two massive, sports-themed hangouts on the downtown waterfront, but there are also similarities. Both are big, both have multiple big screens, and both have rinks where live contests can be watched. Finally, both are long awaited and desperately needed additions to an area of town that once boasted little or no entertainment options. How far we’ve come. It must be noted that RiverWorks is also one of the most popular special event venues in the area and has recently added a brewery.

 

Best sports bar (northtowns)

Amherst Pizza & Ale House

55 Crosspoint Pkwy., Getzville; 625-7100 or amherstpizzaandalehouse.com

The decor might be best described as “frat house meets man cave,” but there are plenty of screens (including four centrally suspended in jumbotron configuration) to keep patrons entertained. A nicely curated beer list and half-price drink specials during games is a major win, especially when the teams don’t. Finally, Ale House’s pepperoni pizza is an absolute ode to excess and must be seen to be believed.

 

Best sports bar (southtowns)

J.P. Fitzgerald’s

4236 Clark St., Hamburg; 649-4025 or jpfitzgeralds.com

This warm, attractive Irish pub has the beer selection and multiple big screens expected of any sports bar as well as a full menu. There’s also a popular darts scene and regular travel packages to Ireland (natch), Spain, Portugal, Germany, and Italy.

 

To keep up with the top restaurants, best chefs, finest bakeries, wineries, distilleries, and breweries + more all year round—subscribe to Buffalo Spree today!

 

Edit ModuleShow Tags

Recommended Reads

  1. WNY's Women of Food
    There is no question that women are well represented in every area of Buffalo’s food and beverage industry. Take a look...
  2. Mazza and Juniper
    Two strong-willed vintners are making waves in this underappreciated AVA
  3. Style / Holiday wear that glitters and glows
    Beautiful gowns and a modern take of Victorian opulence
  4. Starting from scratch
    Creating a home above Raclettes restaurant
  5. At the bar / Lucky Day
    Cocktails, snacks, and style

Add your comment: