Buffalo Spree's Guide to Fresh Turkey

Looking for a fresh turkey? Here’s a resource that will help.


We’ve checked with each of these farms, and—for convenience’s sake—we’ve included some local vendors who can connect their customers with high-quality, humanely raised turkeys. Many farms start taking reservations for fresh Thanksgiving turkeys as early as spring and most sell out well before November. Several do reserve a few, and there are always a couple people who sign up for a turkey but cancel their order, so it doesn’t hurt to call and ask.


Always Something Farm

Corfu, Genesee County;  716-536-2135


Pick up: At farm on 344 Sumner Rd.

Traditional breed: Broad Breasted Bronze and Broad Breasted White, $4.25/lb

Notes: locally milled feed, pasture raised

As of press time, booked for turkeys; are taking names for waiting list


Dizpenza’s Meat Market and Slaughterhouse

Ransomville, Niagara County

716-791-3400, dispenzas.com


Pick up: At store on 3130 Ridge Rd.

Traditional Breed: Broad Breasted White, $3.69/lb

Notes: Closed Monday and Tuesday, free range, no hormones, steroids, or antibiotics 


Farmers & Artisans

Main St., Snyder, NY

716-633-2830, farmersandartisans.com

Pick up: At store on 4557 Main St.; on Wednesday, November 14, 10am-7pm

Traditional Breed: Turkeys from Oink and Gobble Farm in Interlaken, NY, and Red Gate Grocers in Ithaca, NY, $4.50/lb

Notes: all natural turkeys are raised on pasture without the use of antibiotics or hormones; fed non-GMO feed; order by Friday, October 19; contact store for availability


Good Grass Farm

Ashville, Chautauqua County

716-782-3322, goodgrassfarm.com

Pick up: At farm on 2943 Open Meadows Rd.; Monday and Tuesday prior to Thanksgiving

Traditional breed: Broad Breasted White; Pasture Raised Heritage Turkeys, $4.50/lb

Notes: Pasture raised; preorder well ahead (by July 1st for following Thanksgiving)


Humble Homestead

Youngstown, Niagara County




Pick up: At farm on Lockport Road

Traditional breed: Broad Breasted White, Heritage breed: Narragansett, $6.50/lb

Notes: Humanely raised, organically fed pastured poultry; orders taken in advance for Thanksgiving—availability is limited, please call


Jacob’s Acres

Corfu, Genesee County

585-813-1375, jacobsacresfarm.com

Pick up: At farm on 2555 Richley Rd.

Traditional breed: Broad Breasted Bronze, $4/lb; $5 processing fee

Notes: Pasture raised; pesticide free, not medicated


Lexington Co-op

Buffalo, NY

716-886- 2667, lexington.coop

Pick up: 807 Elmwood Ave. or 1678 Hertel Ave.

Traditional Breed: Plainville Farms, raised in New York and Pennsylvania, $1.99/lb - $3.99/lb* organic; Wendel Farms, East Concord, $2.69/lb*; Stonewood Farm, Vermont, $3.29/lb* (*Prices may vary)

Notes: No need to preorder; from 10–30 pounds; humanely raised in well-ventilated barns, vegetarian fed, no antibiotics, preservatives, nitrates, or hormones


The Natural Link

Lewiston, Niagara County

716-754-1199, @TheNaturalLink, 

Pick up: At store on105 Portage Rd.; Call for prices and to reserve


Sojourner Farm

Olean, Cattaraugus County

716-372-4255, sojournerfarm.com

Pick up: At farm on 943 East Windfall Rd.

Traditional breed: Broad Breasted White; $5/lb

Notes: Pasture raised; certified organic feed; reserve ahead


Wendel’s Poultry Farm

East Concord, Chautauqua County

716-592-2299, wendelspoultryfarm.com

Pick up: At farm on 12246 Baughn St., Rte. 240; Call for prices and to reserve

Traditional breed: Broad Breasted White

Notes: Grain-fed; no byproducts, growth stimulants, hormones, or preservatives


Have a happy, healthy Thanksgiving!


Edit ModuleShow Tags

Recommended Reads

  1. Outrages and insights
    Buffalo’s elected leadership is a sorry lot
  2. In the Field / Kindred Kreek
    Keeping up with the demand for locally raised protein
  3. Heritage Businesses in WNY
    Stories of Buffalo’s oldest businesses connected with the history of the region
  4. The Review / 773 North  
    New American cuisine shines at a Grand Island bistro
  5. Queen City Roller Girls: A roller girl comes full circle
    The end of an era and the start of something new